When it comes to brightening up your eye area and hiding those pesky dark circles, regular use of eye creams can be great. However, for a quick and effective solution to camouflage shadows, nothing beats a good under-eye concealer. Personally dealing with persistent dark circles (thanks, Claire !), I’ve tested numerous under-eye concealers, both new and old. In the list below, I’ve rounded up the top 5 best concealers that cater to every skin type and concern. Whether you prefer sheer or full-coverage formulas, these concealers will help cover discoloration and shadows without caking, creasing, or flaking. With this selection, you’re almost guaranteed to find your perfect match.
Our top picks for best under-eye concealer of 2024:
- Best Budget: e.l.f. Cosmetics 16HR Camo Concealer
- Best Matte: NARS Soft Matte Concealer
- Best Natural Finish: NYX Professional Makeup Bare with Me Concealer Serum
- Best Shade Range: A N Skin – Brightning Eye Concealer
- Best Anti-Aging Under-Eye Concealer: It Cosmetics Under Eye Full Coverage Concealer
1. e.l.f. Cosmetics 16HR Camo Concealer
Price: $7.00
The e.l.f. 16hr Camo Concealer has become my go-to for flawless skin. With its full coverage that lasts all day, it effectively conceals dark circles and blemishes. I chose the Medium Sand shade, and the recommendation to match by the bottle image was spot on. The large doe foot applicator made application easy, and the creamy formula allowed for precise coverage. What stands out is the formula—highly pigmented, thick, and matte, it doesn’t settle into fine lines. The concealer also includes Avocado Oil for moisture and Kaolin Clay to control shine. I love that it’s cruelty-free and vegan, aligning with my values. Affordable and effective, the e.l.f. 16hr Camo Concealer is a must-have in my makeup routine.
2. NARS Soft Matte Concealer
Price: $7.00
This NARS concealer impressed us significantly during our testing, particularly for its ability to cover blemishes and brighten the under-eye area. Its buildable full-coverage formula is excellent for camouflaging dark circles and discoloration. What sets it apart is the soft matte finish, offering a more hydrating and dimensional look compared to other matte options. Despite being a matte formula in a pot, its surprisingly creamy texture makes blending a breeze. While it may highlight dry patches, overall, it provides a remarkably smooth appearance. Additionally, it effectively conceals red blemishes and helps control oil around breakouts.
3. NYX Professional Makeup Bare with Me Concealer Serum
Price: $11.97
We absolutely adore NYX Professional concealer, a standout in our exploration of the best drugstore concealers. Our admiration has only deepened as we continued testing. The serum-like formula is incredibly lightweight and easy to blend, leaving us awestruck by its skin-like appearance once it sets. While it doesn’t provide super full coverage, its versatility shines through—you can sheer it out for a light touch or build it up to achieve medium-to-full coverage. Although we noticed a bit of creasing in prominent under-eye lines, it’s easily manageable by gently tapping out the creased areas with fingertips. Beyond its smooth and subtly radiant finish under the eyes, some of our editors even use it as a foundation due to its weightless texture, beautiful coverage, and natural finish.
4. A N Skin – Brightning Eye Concealer
Price: $47.00
I am beyond impressed with this 5-in-1 under-eye treatment from A|N Skin & Beauty. It’s not just a concealer – it’s a complete solution for addressing various concerns around the delicate under-eye area.
The cooling and soothing applicator make the application process a breeze, providing a refreshing sensation that instantly wakes up my tired eyes. The formula effectively conceals imperfections while working to defend against signs of aging. I’ve noticed a visible improvement in the appearance of dark circles, crow’s feet, and even wrinkles. It truly lives up to its claim of being the perfect eye brightener.
The broad-spectrum protection with SPF 50+ is a game-changer for me. I no longer need a separate concealer for dark circles and sunscreen – this product does it all. The fact that it’s waterproof and sweat-resistant ensures lasting coverage throughout the day, even in humid weather.
A|N Skin & Beauty’s dark eye circle remover is now a staple in my skincare routine. The infusion of antioxidants adds an extra layer of defense, making it an effective treatment for my dark under eyes. I love how it helps to de-puff and calm my under-eye area, making it an enjoyable part of my daily routine.
5. It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Anti-Aging Concealer
Price: $29.00
IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Waterproof Concealer is a popular choice for those wanting effective coverage for dark circles, fine lines, redness, and discoloration. It’s known for its waterproof formula, ensuring your makeup stays intact throughout the day. Beyond concealing, it contains anti-aging ingredients for a youthful look. I appreciate its natural finish and the substantial amount provided in each package (0.4 fl oz). If you’re seeking a reliable, long-lasting concealer with added skincare benefits, this product might be a great fit for you.
How to choose the best under-eye concealer
Choosing the best under-eye concealer depends on your specific needs and skin type. Identify your concerns, such as dark circles or fine lines, and select a concealer that addresses those issues. Match the shade to your skin tone and consider the formulation—creamy for dry skin, liquid for versatility. Check if the concealer offers additional benefits like hydration or anti-aging properties. Read reviews for insights and, if possible, test the product before purchasing. Consulting with makeup professionals can also provide helpful guidance. Remember, finding the right concealer may involve some experimentation to see what works best for you.
Conclusion
These under-eye concealers cater to various skin types and concerns, from sheer to full coverage. Whether you’re dealing with dark circles, discoloration, or the need for a quick brightening fix, this selection ensures you find your perfect match.